I’ve never done this before. Last Friday, I just got slammed, and didn’t get my musing out. That’s not the thing I’ve never done before to which I am referring. Being unable to get my musing out has happened a few times in the two decades I’ve been writing these musings. It is somewhat unusual that I didn’t at least get a note or apology out that day, or after Shabbat, but it just didn’t happen this time. Here’s what makes it unusual. I had a musing written and ready to go, and it was simply the mechanics of getting it sent out that stopped me. I suppose I could have sent it out after Shabbat, but I didn’t. So here’s what I’ve not done before – I am sending out my thoughts for last Shabbat, for Shabbat Hol HaMoeid Sukkot, today, and not sending out a new (or even recycled) musing for this week’s parahsa “B’reishit..” I do commend to you the musings Ihave written for parashat B’reishit before, listed at the end of this musing. I do hope you’ll read them. Here, however, I present you with the thoughts I had last week for Shabbat Hol Hamoeid Sukkot.
Random Musing Before Shabbat – Shabbat Hol Hamoeid Sukkot 5778 – Unhappy Comparisons
Talk about a nightmare! I had been reading through the Torah reading for Shabbat Hol Hamoeid Sukkot and came to the famous words of Exodus 34:6-7. The passage from which the thirteen attributes of mercy were derived.
Before I could stop it, the thought came unbidden into my head how this all feels a little well, Trumpian. No, it cannot be. I must not allow myself to be drawn into making a comparison between Ad”nai and DJT.
Yet there it is. It’s that b’tzelem El”him/b’tzelem anashim duality and balance that often comes up in my musings. If we are in the image of G”d then vice versa – and all the best that is in G”d can be found in us, and the best of us in G”d – but also all the worst that is in G”d can be found in us and all the worst that is in us can be found in G”d.
The well worn words of Exodus 34:6-7, which we also just heard, repeatedly, during the Yamim Noraim are boastful, prideful, even a touch arrogant. They have a very “and only I can fix it” quality.
Now, you might argue that, unlike the mere mortal DJT, G”d actually has a reasonably legitimate claim to be able to fix what ails our planet and our species – though for some, G”d’s failure to do so over the last few millennia call into question whether that is truly the case. What is hubris and narcissistic personality disorder for some may be ineffable Divine behavior for others.
יְהוָֹה ׀ יְהֹוָה אֵל רַחוּם וְחַנּוּן אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם וְרַב־חֶסֶד וֶֽאֱמֶֽת: נֹצֵר חֶסֶד לָֽאֲלָפִים נֹשֵׂא עָוֹן וָפֶשַׁע וְחַטָּאָה וְנַקֵּה לֹא יְנַקֶּה פֹּקֵד ׀ עֲוֹן אָבוֹת עַל־בָּנִים וְעַל־בְּנֵי בָנִים עַל־שִׁלֵּשִׁים וְעַל־רִבֵּעִֽים
G”d, as self-described, extends kindness and forgiveness unto a thousand generations. However, there’s a contradiction here – G”d is forgiving, but not all-forgiving. G”d may not be interested in building a wall, but G”d certainly seems interested in punishing those who transgress, even unto the third and fourth generations. G”d, apparently, does not find much value in punishing a family line for transgressions of their forebears beyond a few generations. One might ask why even extend punishment beyond the generation of those who transgressed?Is this simply tactic – is it the stick to the carrot? Are those of us who support DACA and the Dream Act more benevolent and forgiving than G”d? I’d certainly not like to believe this was the case. Yet I fear that there are those who use the biblical example to justify their opposition to DACA, and who find no fault in visiting the parental sin of illegal immigration upon the children.
The rabbis and commentators would have us exegete only the positive virtues from these verses, conveniently ignoring the consequences part. That is the sort of exegesis that is, for me, whitewashing and cherry-picking. These verses clearly insinuate that there is a place for punishment, and that G”d visits punishment not just on those who sin, but on their descendants, at least for a few generations. How does this square with the idea that the gates of t’shuvah are always open? Are children, grandchildren,and great-grandchildren expected to make expiation for the sins of their parents/grandparents/great-grandparents before they are even eligible to seek expiation for their own transgressions? What kind of system is that? Either the gates of t’shuvah are always open, or they aren’t. How we view this biblical dilemma can hold great import for how we might view the prospect of allowing illegal immigrants a path to legal residence. I fear that, based on these verses, G”d might not be so quick to approve of that. That is a G”d that I find troubling.
Perhaps I am making too much of this. I am not a Dawkins, chastising and calling out religion for all the ills of society. However, although I remain a person of faith, there is much in our Jewish faith, as well as other faiths that are questionable, may have been used to justify many things we now find repugnant, and are, perhaps, irredeemable.
The thirteen attributes of mercy aren’t irredeemable, but like so many things in our faith, we carefully tiptoe around the difficult things. I fear that, to some extent, we must accept that our sacred texts may have contributed, intentionally or unintentionally, to some less than positive things. We can’t simply chalk it up to the humans using the text in this manner, for that’s very much a “guns don’t kill people, people kill people, and that’s a slippery slope indeed. Just like we are exhorted to pray to G”d and row towards shore, we should use our sacred texts and liturgy to promote peace and righteousness, while acknowledging the warts and imperfections within them.
I am still unhappy these sorts of comparisons are where my musings led me this week, but I’ll take the bad with good for now, in hopes that the good will prevail. With G”d’s help and ours may it be so.
Shabbat Shalom and Moadim L’simcha,
©2017 by Adrian A. Durlester
Other Musings – on Parashat B’reisheet
B’reishit 5777-Something Good (Redeeming Cain?)
B’reisheet 5776 – Temptation
B’reisheet 5775 – One Favorite Things (not a typo!)
B’reisheet 5774 – Toldot Adrian
B’reishit 5773 – Mixing Metaphors
B’reishit 5772 – The Unified Field Theorem of the Twelve Steps
B’reishit 5771 – B’reishit Bara Anashim
B’reishit 5770 – One G”d, But Two Trees?
B’reishit 5769 – Do Fences Really Make Good Neighbors
B’reishit 5767-Many Beginnings
Bereshit 5766-Kol D’mei Akhikha
Bereshit 5765 (5760)-Failing to Understand-A Learning Experience
Bereshit 5764-Gd’s Regrets
Bereshit 5762–The Essential Ingredient
Bereshit 5763–Striving to be Human
Bereshit 5761–Chava’s Faith
Bereshit 5760-Failing to Understand
Other Musings on Sukkot and Simchat Torah
Hol HaMoeid Sukkot 5775 – Gog Me With a Spoon
Hol HaMoeid Sukkot 5774 – Godot is Waiting for the Bald Soprano at the Zoo
Sukkot III 5772 – Fragility
Sukkot I 5770 – Fire and Rain
Sukkot 5767-Precious Congealed Light – Or Y’kator V’kipa’on
Sukkot 5764–Bayom Hazeh
Sukkot 5763–Sukkot Time Travel
Shemini Atzeret/Simchat Torah 5770 – Circles Can Bite You in the Tuchis
Sh’mini Atzeret/Simkhat Torah 5767 – Joyful and Glad of Heart
Simchat Torah 5766–Have We Met The Ally And Is They Us?
Simchat Torah 5757-5765-Unbroken Circle (With additions for each year)
Simchat Torah 5764-Circling the Torah–A Story of Chelm
Simchat Torah 5762–Not So Fast