Random Musing Before Shabbat – Vayeishev 5769 – Herding Cats

Eleven years ago, I found myself focusing on a seemingly unimportant part of

parashat Vayeshev, which I’d like to revisit now. In Bereshit 37:14 Yaakov (Israel) sends Yosef to see how his brothers and the

sheep are doing. Not just to check on his brothers. Not just to check on the

sheep. But to check on both. Clearly, Yaakov values both his sons and his

flock. Well, of course he does. His sons are of his flesh and blood. His sheep

are his livelihood. It’s a pretty interdependent relationship.

In today’s topsy-turvy world, I see far too often situations in which people

either worry about only the sons, or only the sheep (or sadly, not worrying

about either.)  I have been in board and business meetings where the only

concern is the money (the sheep) with little or no regard for the people. Rules are rules, policies are policies. The bottom line is all that matters.

People are treated like sheep-whoops-well, actually, no, they’re not, in the

modern sense of that turn of phrase-because if they were Yaakov’s sheep they

would have been looked after. Funny how all of a sudden the way we treat sheep

has become an example of negative treatment in our society. What a beautiful

irony. It’s a real commentary on how our values
have changed over time. And it highlights a certain foolishness on our
part. Herding people must be as difficult as herding cats, yet we still
live in a world where people try to herd other people like sheep. But,
like cats, we are pretty difficult to herd. Or are we? The GMs, IBMs,
Microsofts, Googles, Apples, Archer-Daniel-Midlands, DeBeers, Wal-Marts
et al of the world seem to owe a lot of their success to their ability
to get people to herd more like sheep than like cats (or people.)
Without this ability, mass marketing would be for naught.

Nevertheless, as I opined 11 years ago, balance is
necessary. I’ve seen many situations where we focus so much attention
on the people

(the sons) that we forget the livelihood (the sheep.) That’s not such a good

idea either. The workplace is rife with businesses and institutions following

the latest management fad. And, like the good Dilbert-Principle based places

they are, they spend all this time on employee morale and treatment and

completely forget the product. And how many times have we each found ourselves

in a  circumstance where we are making decisions that ultimately are good for

neither the brothers or the sheep because we are afraid of hurting the

brothers’ feelings? Most of us (hopefully) have difficulties with having to

give someone a negative evaluation, fire them, lay them off. Well, it won’t

make it any nicer a task, or any easier, but we can learn to take into

consideration the needs of the sons and the sheep.- the employee and the

company, the doctor and the patient, the customer and the clerk. If the

brothers and the sheep aren’t a good match for each other, it doesn’t make much

sense for them to be together.

In our current economic morass, it’s easy to blame management or labor,
big business or unions, lobbyists or lobbyists (let’s face it, even the
socially responsible causes need and use lobbyists.) In this case, I’d say we are all part of the problem-and the solution.

When we go out looking after things, we should remember to look after our

brothers/sisters and our flocks. It’s a good lesson in balance and  in perspective.

It’s a lesson in finding the middle ground that benefits all. I’m sure the

sheep and the brothers can be used a metaphors for some aspect of many

different situations. I’ve only cited ones that happen to be on my mind.

This Shabbat, why not look to identify the brothers and the sheep in your

life, and teach yourself to look after both. The next time you find the

"brothers are most important" camp fighting with the "sheep are the most

important camp" why not remind them of the simple lesson this one verse from

Torah can teach us.

To all of you and your loved ones a

Shabbat Shalom,


©2008 by Adrian A. Durlester


About migdalorguy

Jewish Educator & Musician, Technology Nerd and all around nice Renaissance guy
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s